$240 is good. Venmo an option? I think they charge a 3% buyer protection fee to the seller. I can cover that in the cost (so $247.20 total). That work?
Don't underestimate the number of boneheads like me out there that will back into another one of their vehicles in their own driveway, but do so on the driver's side. Doh!
I'm guessing there's plenty of people looking to replace just one broken light. If you change your mind, let me know...